Why Private Equity Firms Should Use BlackmoreConnects Recruiting Division Over Traditional Markets

Written By: Gerald O’Dwyer II The PE Guru — Blackmore Partners, Inc | January 30th, 2025

I was reading Bloomberg, and I started thinking about how I advocate the importance of understanding what PE is concerned with in general. I have talked about how you cannot operate in a vacuum—you need to have context about your funders. When it comes to hiring for portfolio companies, the context is decisive. Too often, private equity (PE) firms approach hiring through traditional channels that are ill-equipped to handle the nuances of PE-backed businesses.

At Blackmore Partners, we’ve spent nearly two decades refining a recruiting model that aligns talent acquisition with investment theses, operational imperatives, and exit strategies. Our recruiting division, BlackmoreConnects, was built to solve a persistent problem in the lower middle market: finding executive leadership that can drive enterprise value, sustain growth, and position a company for a lucrative exit.

The BlackmoreConnects Difference: Executive-First, Thesis-Driven Recruiting

Unlike traditional recruiters, we don’t just fill vacancies—we engineer leadership solutions tailored to the PE environment. As an independent sponsor since 2005, Blackmore Partners has always prioritized executives first. We believe the right talent determines the success of any investment. Our recruiting model is designed to:

  • Align executive hires with the investment thesis, ensuring strategic fit from Day 1.
  • Select candidates who thrive in a high-expectation, performance-driven PE culture.
  • Build leadership teams capable of executing a value creation plan through an exit.
  • Offer a repeatable, measurable, and scalable process to reduce risk and maximize returns.

Case Study: Reddy Ice

At Reddy Ice, a PE-backed portfolio company, the challenge was finding senior leadership who could balance revenue growth with EBITDA discipline while preparing for a potential exit. Traditional recruiters lacked the nuanced understanding of how PE works and were unable to match candidates who could deliver both short-term operational improvements and long-term strategic positioning.

BlackmoreConnects deployed a structured, systematic process to identify executives with direct experience in highly fragmented industries and operational optimization. By leveraging our deep executive network, we successfully placed an SVP of Sales who understood the PE playbook and was able to drive margin expansion while supporting the firm’s buy-and-build strategy.

Case Study: AEFP Group

AEFP Group, a PE-backed aerospace machining company, needed to hire a Chief Commercial Officer (CCO) with a mix of operational excellence and strategic vision. The challenge was sourcing a candidate with both sector expertise and a proven track record of executing in a PE environment.

Traditional recruiters failed to find a candidate who fit AEFP’s compensation structure, incentives, and growth expectations. Our BlackmoreConnects team engaged directly with the executive market, presenting multiple candidates who were already aligned with PE-backed company dynamics. We facilitated negotiations between AEFP and the preferred candidate, ensuring the compensation package aligned with the company’s financial position while still incentivizing long-term value creation.

Why BlackmoreConnects Outperforms Traditional Recruiting Firms

  1. Deep PE Industry Expertise: Traditional recruiters don’t understand the investor-operator mindset needed for PE-backed businesses. We do.
  1. Investment Thesis-Driven Recruitment: Every candidate we present is aligned with the investment strategy and value creation plan.
  1. Speed & Efficiency: Our process minimizes recruitment time, ensuring portfolio companies can execute quickly.
  1. Pre-Vetted Executive Network: We provide access to a curated database of 60,000+ executives with direct PE experience.
  1. Exit-Oriented Hiring: We focus on leaders who understand value creation through a structured exit strategy.
  1. Cultural Fit Matters: We don’t just place candidates—we ensure alignment with company culture and operational dynamics.
  1. Lower Risk, Higher ROI: Hiring mistakes in PE are expensive. Our repeatable and data-driven methodology minimizes hiring risks.
  1. Access to Buy-and-Build Specialists: We find executives who have successfully executed roll-up strategies.
  1. Succession Planning & Continuity: We help PE firms build a pipeline of leadership talent to ensure long-term success.
  1. Long-Term Partnership Approach: We don’t just find talent; we integrate recruitment into a firm’s overall strategy.

The Bottom Line: BlackmoreConnects Delivers ROI-Driven Recruitment

PE firms cannot afford to take a generic approach to hiring. Every executive hire is a critical piece of the investment strategy, and the wrong fit can derail a deal. Traditional recruiters operate on a transactional basis, while BlackmoreConnects embeds itself into the firm’s value creation plan to ensure long-term success.

At Blackmore Partners, we are investors first, and we apply that mindset to every hire we make for PE-backed companies. Whether you need a CEO to drive a carve-out, a CFO to scale operations, or a commercial leader to execute a buy-and-build strategy, BlackmoreConnects provides the talent solutions that directly contribute to enterprise value and successful exits.

If you’re ready to elevate your recruiting strategy and drive superior investment outcomes, BlackmoreConnects is your competitive advantage.